NSG 4000: Application of Evidence-Based Research | Week 3 – Dropbox Assignment – Research Critique | Homework Solution
NSG 4000: Application of Evidence-Based Research
Week 3 – Dropbox Assignment – Research Critique
***This assignment utilizes TurnItIn. When you submit this assignment to the assignment drop box, it will automatically be submitted to TurnItIn. You will receive an Originality Score along with an Originality Report that should be carefully reviewed. If revisions need to be made to your assignment, you will be able to make additional submissions, and you will quickly receive updated Originally feedback. It is important to plan ahead so that you have enough time to review your originality feedback and make any revisions to your assignment before the final due date. Please see instructions for using TurnItIn in the Course Welcome module under Useful Resources.
Directions:
For this assignment, you will critique two scholarly peer-reviewed research articles using the template provided. Use the primary quantitative and primary qualitative research articles you shared in Weeks 2 and 3 discussions (SEE BOTH ARTICLES ATTACHED). Both articles must be recent and published this year in a nursing journal. Email your instructor the two articles by Wednesday in Week 3 if you need guidance based on the discussion grading feedback.
Do not use any direct quotes when completing this assignment. As shown on the template, an APA formatted title and references pages are required. Delete the questions from the template before you submit the assignment for grading.
Use this template: Article Critique Template (SEE TEMPLATE ATTACHED)
Research Critique Grading Rubric
| Criteria | Ratings |
| Background
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent background where the author(s) foundation for why anyone would care about this topic was clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Importance of Study
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context of the importance of the topic to nursing was clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Purpose
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent purpose of the study clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Literature Review
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent literature review where the identified gap in the literature that was clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Research Design
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context identifying the correct research design for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Sample
|
10 pts
Exceptional Excellent context meeting the following criteria were clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles: · Description of the sample (Who? How many? Exclusion and inclusion criteria?) · Description of the sampling method (sample selection process)? · Sample size |
| Data Collection
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context where the data collection procedures were clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Analysis
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context where the data analysis was clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Findings/Results
|
5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context where the study outcomes and validity of the results were clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Limitations | 5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context where study limitations were clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Conclusions | 5 pts
Exceptional Excellent context explaining the conclusions supported by data were clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Practice Changes | 10 pts
Exceptional Excellent context clearly explaining the study’s impact on practice changes for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Research Recommendations | 10 pts
Exceptional Excellent future research recommendations were clearly stated for both the quantitative and qualitative articles. |
| Grammar, Mechanics and Organization | 10 pts
Exceptional Excellent grammar, mechanics and organization with no errors in in the following: spelling, grammar, word order, word usage, and punctuation; logical sequence of paragraphs; and use of complete sentences. The template provided was used to complete the assignment. |
| APA Format for Page Set Up, In-Text Citations and References. | 10 pts
Exceptional Excellent APA format meeting all of the 3 criteria for both articles: · Title page is free from APA errors. · Correctly APA formatted in-text citations of the references used. · Correct APA formatting on the references page. |
Article Critique
Your Name
Galen College of Nursing
NSG 4000: Application of Evidence-Based Research
Instructor’s Name
Assignment Due Date
Delete all yellow highlighted text from this template and replace them with your content.
Quantitative Critique
| Article’s APA Formatted In-Text Citation | Be sure that the article is current and published this year in a nursing journal. |
| Background Information | · Did the authors lay the foundation for why anyone would care about this topic? How?
|
| Importance of the Study | · Were you convinced of the importance of this work to nursing? Why?
|
| Purpose | · What was the purpose of this research? |
| Literature Review | · What was the gap in the literature to convince you that this study was needed? Get Food Footprint Analysis Essay Help
|
| Research Design | · What was the research design? |
| Population/Sample | · Describe the sample? (Who? How many? Exclusion and inclusion criteria?)
· Describe the sampling method? (Sample selection process)
· Was the sample size large enough? (why or why not? Consider study purpose)
|
| Data Collection | · How was data collected?
· Were reliability and validity discussed? Explain.
|
| Analysis/Stats | · What statistical testing were done?
|
| Findings/Results | · Are the study outcomes clinically important?
· Were the results of the study valid?
|
| Limitations | · What were the study limitations?
|
| Conclusions | · Were the authors’ conclusions supported by the data? Why or why not?
|
| Practice Changes | · Were the results of this study impactful enough to encourage changes in your practice? Why or why not?
|
| Recommendations for Future Research | · What future research needs to be done? (Create a stronger design? Replicate with a larger sample size? Replicate with a different population? Use different tools? Measure more meaningful outcomes?)
|
Qualitative Critique
| Article’s APA Formatted In-Text Citation | Ensure that the article is current and published this year in a nursing journal. |
| Background Information | · Did the authors lay the foundation for why anyone would care about this topic? How?
|
| Importance of the Study | · Were you convinced of the importance of this work to nursing? Why? |
| Purpose | · What is the purpose of this research? |
| Literature Review | · What was the gap in the literature to convince you that this study was needed? |
| Research Design | · What was the research design?
|
| Sample | · Describe the sample? (Who? How many? Exclusion and inclusion criteria?)
· Describe the sampling method (sample selection process)?
· Was the sample size large enough? (why or why not? Consider the study purpose)
|
| Data Collection | · How was data collected?
|
| Analysis | · Did the data analysis process seem appropriate? (consider type of data, size of sample)
|
| Findings/Results | · Are the study outcomes clinically important?
· Were the results of the study valid? (Trustworthy and credible)
|
| Limitations | · What were the study limitations?
|
| Conclusions | · Were the authors’ conclusions supported by the data? Why or why not?
|
| Practice Changes | · Were the results of this study impactful enough to encourage changes in your practice? Why or why not?
|
| Recommendations for Future Research | · What future research needs to be done? (Create a stronger design? Replicate with a larger sample size? Replicate with a different population? Measure more meaningful outcomes?)
|
References
Provide the full references for the two articles in APA format. The references page will include a hanging indentation for each source. Ensure that each reference has a corresponding in-text citation. See your APA Manual and the APA resources posted to the course for reference formatting.
